Multicomp Pro 3D Printer Filaments Road Test

Name: Review Multicomp Pro 3D Printer Filaments, PLA and PETG
Rating: 4.30 (5 reviews)

Steve524 11 months ago

View table of contents

RoadTest: Review Multicomp Pro 3D Printer Filaments, PLA and PETG

Author: Steve524

Creation date: 16 Jul 2024

Evaluation Type: Passives

Did you receive all parts the manufacturer stated would be included in the package?: True

What other parts do you consider comparable to this product?: na

What were the biggest problems encountered?: Build plate adhesion issues with MC011473 and MC011440.

Detailed Review:

This Road Test was mainly just to test the capabilities of each filament, overall the products this company offers are very very good and I would highly recommend using them.

Multicomp_Review_v0.0.1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 07/16/2024

Multicomp_Review_Matrix_v0.0.1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 07/16/20246888.Filament_Test_Data_Matrix_v0.0.2.xlsx

Testing Device Pictures --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Product Documents --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Product Pictures --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All Products In Boxes

MC002547

MC011440

MC011473

MC005454

All Test Sticks --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Benchey Test Pictures --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Test Reports and Videos --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

MC002547 1mm

MC002547 1.25mm

MC011473 1mm

MC011473 1.25mm

MP005454 1mm

MP005454 1.25mm

MP011440 1mm

MP005454 1.25mm

Learn more about Newark's information on Multicomp Pro's 3D Printer Filaments

Top Comments

Fred27 11 months ago +1

So, there's lots of raw data here, but this road test leaves me no clearer on whether these filaments are any good or not.
Steve524 11 months ago in reply to kmikemoo +1

You may have missed the documentation near the top of page.
cstanton 11 months ago +1

Hey Steve524 ,

The comprehensive assessment of the filament is great.

When you have the opportunity would you please edit your RoadTest Review with a paragraph on each test, or at least introduce the batch…

cstanton 11 months ago in reply to Steve524

I hope your house move goes smoothly! Such things can be very disruptive.
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
Steve524 11 months ago in reply to cstanton

Thank you, I will see what I can do, I am very busy with my move into a new home currently.
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
cstanton 11 months ago

Hey Steve524 ,

The comprehensive assessment of the filament is great.

When you have the opportunity would you please edit your RoadTest Review with a paragraph on each test, or at least introduce the batch of tests to complement the results with an explanation as to what the test is and how it demonstrates the capability of the filament? Along with your personal opinion of the results.

I appreciate that you may have this in the PDF document that you inserted at the start of the review, for readability it would be best if the text of this was directly posted into the review rather than inserted as a PDF.

This would add significant value to your hard work and help people reading it further appreciate it.

Thank you,
- Cancel
- Up +1 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
colporteur 11 months ago in reply to Steve524

I'm curious what were the expectation you set in your Roadtest application?

I going to print a test strip for each filament and a boat model for each filament and provide data, seems to be a pretty low bar for a Roadtest.

The standard is not what the person that read the reviews expects but rather what is expected from a Roadtest.

If you met the expectations set in your application then your golden. If you failed to meet those expectations, the trying to do better the next time is not an answer

Did the Roadtest expectation change due to your move?
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
Steve524 11 months ago in reply to kmikemoo

I'm sorry it was not to your standards I am currently moving into a new home and do not have a lab I do have a life outside of element 14 I will try to do better next time thank you...
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
kmikemoo 11 months ago in reply to Steve524

I saw the document at the beginning.
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
Steve524 11 months ago in reply to kmikemoo

You may have missed the documentation near the top of page.
- Cancel
- Up +1 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
kmikemoo 11 months ago in reply to Steve524

Steve524 So... I may be being Captain Obvious, but most RoadTests have a full write-up. We want to read what you did, why you did it and how it turned out.
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
Steve524 11 months ago in reply to Fred27

The road test I did was mainly just to test the capabilities of each filament overall the products this company offers are very very good and I would highly recommend using them.
- Cancel
- Up 0 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel
Fred27 11 months ago

So, there's lots of raw data here, but this road test leaves me no clearer on whether these filaments are any good or not.
- Cancel
- Up +1 Down
- Reply
- More
- Cancel