element14 Community
element14 Community
    Register Log In
  • Site
  • Search
  • Log In Register
  • Members
    Members
    • Benefits of Membership
    • Achievement Levels
    • Members Area
    • Personal Blogs
    • Feedback and Support
    • What's New on element14
  • Learn
    Learn
    • Learning Center
    • eBooks
    • STEM Academy
    • Webinars, Training and Events
    • Learning Groups
  • Technologies
    Technologies
    • 3D Printing
    • FPGA
    • Industrial Automation
    • Internet of Things
    • Power & Energy
    • Sensors
    • Technology Groups
  • Challenges & Projects
    Challenges & Projects
    • Design Challenges
    • element14 presents
    • Project14
    • Arduino Projects
    • Raspberry Pi Projects
    • Project Groups
  • Products
    Products
    • Arduino
    • Dev Tools
    • Manufacturers
    • Raspberry Pi
    • RoadTests & Reviews
    • Avnet Boards Community
    • Product Groups
  • Store
    Store
    • Visit Your Store
    • Choose Another Store
      • Europe
      •  Austria (German)
      •  Belgium (Dutch, French)
      •  Bulgaria (Bulgarian)
      •  Czech Republic (Czech)
      •  Denmark (Danish)
      •  Estonia (Estonian)
      •  Finland (Finnish)
      •  France (French)
      •  Germany (German)
      •  Hungary (Hungarian)
      •  Ireland
      •  Israel
      •  Italy (Italian)
      •  Latvia (Latvian)
      •  
      •  Lithuania (Lithuanian)
      •  Netherlands (Dutch)
      •  Norway (Norwegian)
      •  Poland (Polish)
      •  Portugal (Portuguese)
      •  Romania (Romanian)
      •  Russia (Russian)
      •  Slovakia (Slovak)
      •  Slovenia (Slovenian)
      •  Spain (Spanish)
      •  Sweden (Swedish)
      •  Switzerland(German, French)
      •  Turkey (Turkish)
      •  United Kingdom
      • Asia Pacific
      •  Australia
      •  China
      •  Hong Kong
      •  India
      •  Korea (Korean)
      •  Malaysia
      •  New Zealand
      •  Philippines
      •  Singapore
      •  Taiwan
      •  Thailand (Thai)
      • Americas
      •  Brazil (Portuguese)
      •  Canada
      •  Mexico (Spanish)
      •  United States
      Can't find the country/region you're looking for? Visit our export site or find a local distributor.
  • Translate
  • Profile
The Learning Circuit
  • Challenges & Projects
  • element14 presents
  • The Learning Circuit
  • More
  • Cancel
The Learning Circuit
Documents The Learning Circuit 42: Replacing MLCCs with Polymer Capacitors
  • Documents
  • Polls
  • Files
  • Members
  • Mentions
  • Sub-Groups
  • Tags
  • More
  • Cancel
  • New
The Learning Circuit requires membership for participation - click to join
Actions
  • Share
  • More
  • Cancel
Engagement
  • Author Author: tariq.ahmad
  • Date Created: 25 Dec 2018 3:15 AM Date Created
  • Last Updated Last Updated: 27 Mar 2019 4:05 PM
  • Views 1403 views
  • Likes 8 likes
  • Comments 7 comments
Related
Recommended

The Learning Circuit 42: Replacing MLCCs with Polymer Capacitors

image
Replacing MLCCs with Polymer Capacitors

The Learning Circuit | element14 presents |  Project Videos

 

 

You don't have permission to edit metadata of this video.
Edit media
x
image
Upload Preview
image

Polymer capacitors offer low ESR and high capacitance in a small package. See what happens when a tantalum polymer replaces an MLCC in a DC-to-DC converter. Or, check the result of replacing a traditional electrolytic capacitor with an aluminum polymer. For fun, James shows measurements on a modern switching power supply and goes back to a classic 8-bit favorite, the Commodore 64.

 

 

Take the Polymer Capacitor Quiz

Learn more about Passive Components

Join the Experimenting with Polymer Capacitor Competition

 

Supplemental  Content:

 

  • The Learning Circuit 40: Learning About Polymer Capacitors
  • Measurements from replacing MLCCs with Polymer capacitors (TLC #42 Extra)
  • Why does this C64 electrolytic capacitor have AC applied to it?

 

 

Bill of Material:

 

Part
Test Tools

WXMT MS (Micro Soldering Tweezers)

Weller1Buy NowBuy Now

RTM3004 Oscilloscope

Rohde and Schwarz1Buy NowBuy Now
Power Rail Probe - RT-ZPR20Rohde and Schwarz1Buy NowBuy Now
Handheld DMM (72-7780)Tenma1Buy NowBuy Now
Adjustable Electronics LoadBK1Buy NowBuy Now
PCB HolderPanavise1Buy NowBuy Now
Module
TPS62097EVM Evaluation ModuleTexas Instruments1Buy NowBuy Now
Soldering Supplies
De-Soldering Wick 484-2 (0.05")American Beauty1Buy NowBuy Now
SnPb Solder 0.02" Rosen Core (SPC22130)Duratool1Buy NowBuy Now
SMD291AX Solder Paste, No Clean, SyringeChip Quik1Buy NowBuy Now
SMD291 Solder Flux, No Clean, SyringeChip Quik1Buy NowBuy Now
Capacitors
Original 22uF 0805 Ceramic Capacitors (C2012X7S1A226M125AC)TDK1Buy NowBuy Now
Tantalum Polymer 22uF (T529P226M010AAE200)KEMET1Buy NowBuy Now
470uF 25V Aluminum Polymer (A750MS477M1EAAE015)KEMET2Buy NowBuy Now
2200uF 16V Aluminum Polymer  (RNL1C222MDS1)Nichicon1Buy NowBuy Now
  • polymers
  • polymer capacitor
  • replacing mlccs
  • polymer electrolytic capacitor
  • mlcc alternatives
  • e14presents_baldengineer
  • aluminum polymer capacitor
  • tantalum polymer capacitor
  • Share
  • History
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Sign in to reply

Top Comments

  • DAB
    DAB over 4 years ago +2
    Good video. As you point out, testing is key to understanding how different types of components affect specific circuits. There is much more to engineering than just copying circuit diagrams and putting…
  • Gough Lui
    Gough Lui over 4 years ago +2
    I enjoyed the video along with the (at times) suspenseful moments looking for improvements. I know in the past, I've tended to do "shotgun" style repairs where I will replace capacitors wholesale, mostly…
  • Gough Lui
    Gough Lui over 4 years ago in reply to baldengineer +2
    Thanks for the reply - I can definitely understand especially if you don't have an ESR meter to hand as it isn't necessarily easy to measure or interpret. In fact, I invested in one pretty early on as…
  • baldengineer
    baldengineer over 3 years ago in reply to nmanjofo

    nmanjofo , sadly, that thread is a great example of why I avoid that forum. You have to be careful when changing out polymers in LDO-circuits and switching circuits. The significantly lower ESR can result in control loop stability issues that the original design did not consider. A Pentium4 design is on the verge of the timeframe where polymers were just entering the market. When I was at the capacitor company, we had issues where a supply chain manager swapped out a polymer for a traditional electrolytic in production, which resulted in failures in the field. (As engineers became aware of this issue, design rules were put into place to address that.)

     

    So, for the big bulk electrolytics, you can probably safely replace them. They are usually input filter caps to other regulators and are less sensitive to ESR issues. If they are on the output of a regulator, there could be more issues, especially in the POL (point-of-load) converters that get closer to the processor.

     

    Unfortunately, as that thread shows, there are many design engineers (or want to be engineers) who have never measured the control loop stability of a power supply design.

     

    tldr; can you replace them in a P4 mobo? Maybe. I think the larger electrolytics are probably a safe bet. The smaller surface mounts near a switching regulator, I would be more cautious.

     

    it is said that capacitance of the polymer should be like 1/3 of the original electrolyte cap. Is it like that?

    Unfortunately, it is difficult to make a blanket statement like that. It comes down to the fact that the lower ESR results in better high-frequency performance. However, without characterizing how the control loop responds to that change in impedance is going to be difficult. When designing-in a polymer into a new design, this is one of the advantages. You can typically use a much smaller polymer because of the higher effective capactiance. But in that case, you're able to account for the difference in overall impedance.

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +1 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • nmanjofo
    nmanjofo over 3 years ago

    Hey! Thanks for a great video. I was wondering if I can replace electrolyte caps on my old Pentium4 motherboard with polymers. Do I use the same capacitance or what parameters should I focus on? I've come to several ideas, for, example here

     

    https://www.eevblog.com/forum/beginners/can-be-simple-electrolytic-capacitor-replaced-by-polymer-capacitor/msg750423/?PH…

     

    it is said that capacitance of the polymer should be like 1/3 of the original electrolyte cap. Is it like that?

     

    Thank You!

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • Gough Lui
    Gough Lui over 4 years ago in reply to baldengineer

    Thanks for the reply - I can definitely understand especially if you don't have an ESR meter to hand as it isn't necessarily easy to measure or interpret. In fact, I invested in one pretty early on as I felt it was going to be "useful" but have (admittedly) never attempted to measure leakage current directly in the way you have. Perhaps I should give that one a go someday image.

     

    - Gough

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +2 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • baldengineer
    baldengineer over 4 years ago in reply to Gough Lui

    lui_gough  wrote:

     

    I notice you measured leakage current (related with dissipation factor) to determine if the capacitor electrolyte is still healthy.

     

    Gough, good catch. Something I should have more clear is that I was only trying to evaluate the health of the capacitor. I was not trying to assess the performance capability of the old capacitors. Thinking about what I said in the video, I can see how it might not sit well with some. I specifically said I was using the leakage measurement to determine the electrolyte's life. While a true statement, I might have said it too definitively.

     

    Both ESR and leakage current is used by manufacturers to determine end-of-life for the electrolyte. So to be correct, I should have measured both. However, once one parametrically fails, the capacitor is considered end-of-life. I also like that leakage demonstrates both the dielectric's and electrolyte's health in a single measurement. A healthy dielectric will have a low leakage current, and, a healthy electrolyte will stabilize the current quickly.

     

    All that said, the #1 reason I showed leakage is because it is an easy measurement to make and understand. All you need is a power supply and multimeter. For a video, it was a simple measurement to show. I, like most people, do not have an ESR meter. So to measure ESR, I would have had to use my scope and function generator. Initially, I thought about showing this measurement, but I felt like it slowed down the video too much to explain how it works. (But it is something I want to do a video on at some point.)

     

    Another reason I skipped measuring the ESR is that I don't have any information on the original specs for the capacitors. I have no idea what a good or bad ESR measurement would be for them. With 30 years of electrolyte development, it is possible there is already an order of magnitude difference between the ESR of the original capacitors and their modern equivalent. One might say the same for leakage, but my experience from looking through old datasheets suggest that 1-5% of the CV has not changed much over time. And in this case, going from memory, the leakage after 5 minutes was in that range for the capacitor I measured.

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +1 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • Gough Lui
    Gough Lui over 4 years ago

    I enjoyed the video along with the (at times) suspenseful moments looking for improvements. I know in the past, I've tended to do "shotgun" style repairs where I will replace capacitors wholesale, mostly with nearly-identical capacitance/voltage/technology specs but of a modern make which often results in better performance for vintage gear as modern capacitors generally do better on ESR and leakage.

     

    Forgive my ignorance baldengineer, when you replaced the electrolytic capacitors of the C64, I notice you measured leakage current (related with dissipation factor) to determine if the capacitor electrolyte is still healthy.

     

    I was wondering whether you measured the ESR difference between the old capacitors and the new capacitors, as reduced ESR (to my rather limited knowledge) should improve ripple voltage and frequency response of the capacitor and is the means by which I normally gauge whether an old capacitor would be any good (along with dissipation factor, although I note that that there are only rough guidelines for ESR as that varies from series-to-series so checking datasheets can be useful and sometimes varies quite significantly for different capacitor technologies especially over frequency).

     

    - Gough

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +2 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • DAB
    DAB over 4 years ago

    Good video.

     

    As you point out, testing is key to understanding how different types of components affect specific circuits.

    There is much more to engineering than just copying circuit diagrams and putting components together.

     

    DAB

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +2 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • mayermakes
    mayermakes over 4 years ago

    axials were intended to use with point to point wiring on solderstrips and wirewrap, the naming is similar to radial and axial agricultural crop protection blowers, the leads are attached like the stream of air would go (paralell to the axis-> axial). I only know that from having to remember when I studied viticulture...

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +1 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
element14 Community

element14 is the first online community specifically for engineers. Connect with your peers and get expert answers to your questions.

  • Members
  • Learn
  • Technologies
  • Challenges & Projects
  • Products
  • Store
  • About Us
  • Feedback & Support
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal and Copyright Notices
  • Sitemap
  • Cookies

An Avnet Company © 2023 Premier Farnell Limited. All Rights Reserved.

Premier Farnell Ltd, registered in England and Wales (no 00876412), registered office: Farnell House, Forge Lane, Leeds LS12 2NE.

ICP 备案号 10220084.

Follow element14

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • linkedin
  • YouTube