Hi Cabe,
I like to think that the design process is most efficient when the electrical engineer draws the schematic, does the placement of the critical components and sometimes even routes the critical tracks (placement and critical trackes are very much related). The layouter's job is to finish the routing (less critical tracks) and make sure that the product fulfills the manufacturing rules. The layout is the knowlegde keeper on all the factory/process guidelines/rules. In this case the path to a succesfull first PCB (good enough to send to your customer) is more assured. Assuming ofcourse that the circuit is first breadboarded or silmulated. If this is skipped, the first PCB will have a lot of reworks (wasting time / money)
I agree that experience is key. If your layouter is 'fresh' you have to sit next to him and guide him a lot. This add to his knowlegde. I'm lucky to have a very experienced layouter, so most of the time i leave all the copper artwork to him, but i have to check the design at the end anyway. It is good to have standard checklists.
Best regards,
Enrico Migchels
Power conversion design engineer
Heliox B.V.
Best - The Netherlands
Hi Cabe,
I like to think that the design process is most efficient when the electrical engineer draws the schematic, does the placement of the critical components and sometimes even routes the critical tracks (placement and critical trackes are very much related). The layouter's job is to finish the routing (less critical tracks) and make sure that the product fulfills the manufacturing rules. The layout is the knowlegde keeper on all the factory/process guidelines/rules. In this case the path to a succesfull first PCB (good enough to send to your customer) is more assured. Assuming ofcourse that the circuit is first breadboarded or silmulated. If this is skipped, the first PCB will have a lot of reworks (wasting time / money)
I agree that experience is key. If your layouter is 'fresh' you have to sit next to him and guide him a lot. This add to his knowlegde. I'm lucky to have a very experienced layouter, so most of the time i leave all the copper artwork to him, but i have to check the design at the end anyway. It is good to have standard checklists.
Best regards,
Enrico Migchels
Power conversion design engineer
Heliox B.V.
Best - The Netherlands