element14 Community
element14 Community
    Register Log In
  • Site
  • Search
  • Log In Register
  • Community Hub
    Community Hub
    • What's New on element14
    • Feedback and Support
    • Benefits of Membership
    • Personal Blogs
    • Members Area
    • Achievement Levels
  • Learn
    Learn
    • Ask an Expert
    • eBooks
    • element14 presents
    • Learning Center
    • Tech Spotlight
    • STEM Academy
    • Webinars, Training and Events
    • Learning Groups
  • Technologies
    Technologies
    • 3D Printing
    • FPGA
    • Industrial Automation
    • Internet of Things
    • Power & Energy
    • Sensors
    • Technology Groups
  • Challenges & Projects
    Challenges & Projects
    • Design Challenges
    • element14 presents Projects
    • Project14
    • Arduino Projects
    • Raspberry Pi Projects
    • Project Groups
  • Products
    Products
    • Arduino
    • Avnet Boards Community
    • Dev Tools
    • Manufacturers
    • Multicomp Pro
    • Product Groups
    • Raspberry Pi
    • RoadTests & Reviews
  • Store
    Store
    • Visit Your Store
    • Choose another store...
      • Europe
      •  Austria (German)
      •  Belgium (Dutch, French)
      •  Bulgaria (Bulgarian)
      •  Czech Republic (Czech)
      •  Denmark (Danish)
      •  Estonia (Estonian)
      •  Finland (Finnish)
      •  France (French)
      •  Germany (German)
      •  Hungary (Hungarian)
      •  Ireland
      •  Israel
      •  Italy (Italian)
      •  Latvia (Latvian)
      •  
      •  Lithuania (Lithuanian)
      •  Netherlands (Dutch)
      •  Norway (Norwegian)
      •  Poland (Polish)
      •  Portugal (Portuguese)
      •  Romania (Romanian)
      •  Russia (Russian)
      •  Slovakia (Slovak)
      •  Slovenia (Slovenian)
      •  Spain (Spanish)
      •  Sweden (Swedish)
      •  Switzerland(German, French)
      •  Turkey (Turkish)
      •  United Kingdom
      • Asia Pacific
      •  Australia
      •  China
      •  Hong Kong
      •  India
      •  Korea (Korean)
      •  Malaysia
      •  New Zealand
      •  Philippines
      •  Singapore
      •  Taiwan
      •  Thailand (Thai)
      • Americas
      •  Brazil (Portuguese)
      •  Canada
      •  Mexico (Spanish)
      •  United States
      Can't find the country/region you're looking for? Visit our export site or find a local distributor.
  • Translate
  • Profile
  • Settings
Sensors
  • Technologies
  • More
Sensors
Polls In what situation(s) should an optical sensor (reflective) be applied instead of an ultrasonic sensor?
  • Blog
  • Forum
  • Documents
  • Quiz
  • Events
  • Polls
  • Members
  • Mentions
  • Sub-Groups
  • Tags
  • More
  • Cancel
  • New
Join Sensors to participate - click to join for free!
Actions
  • Share
  • More
  • Cancel
Engagement
  • Author Author: rscasny
  • Date Created: 22 Nov 2020 7:12 PM Date Created
  • Last Updated Last Updated: 11 Oct 2021 3:00 PM
  • Views 856 views
  • Likes 2 likes
  • Comments 4 comments
Related
Recommended

In what situation(s) should an optical sensor (reflective) be applied instead of an ultrasonic sensor?

Poll Question: In what situation(s) should an optical sensor (reflective) be applied instead of an ultrasonic sensor?

  • sensor survey
  • Share
  • History
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Sign in to reply

Top Comments

  • DAB
    DAB over 4 years ago +5
    Difficult question to answer. If you go optical, you need to consider if you are using IR or visible light. In general, both sensor require a rather clean environment. Both are susceptible to particle…
  • michaelkellett
    michaelkellett over 4 years ago +3
    There isn't a single right answer here. I was about to vote for "distance is over 9 m" but then I thought of depth sounders, which both work under water and can sense over much greater distances than 9m…
  • genebren
    genebren over 4 years ago +3
    This is a simple question but the answer as always depends on many factors. The environment that you are operating in will influence your decision. Also cost can be a factor in you decision where ultrasonic…
  • kmikemoo
    kmikemoo over 4 years ago

    Other:  Cost and distance*.  Why the asterisk?  When I think of reflective sensors, I think of entry sensors and garage door safety circuits.  The distance (range) can be 3 feet for a personnel door up to 32 feet for a larger commercial garage door.  One size fits most.  Align the reflector back at the transceiver and you're up and running.  To quote Ron Popeil, "Set it and forget it."  The few ultrasonic sensors I've played with needed to be adjusted to respond correctly to the material being sensed.

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +2 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • genebren
    genebren over 4 years ago

    This is a simple question but the answer as always depends on many factors.  The environment that you are operating in will influence your decision.  Also cost can be a factor in you decision where ultrasonic sensor cost can cost about 100 times more that optical sensors.

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +3 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • michaelkellett
    michaelkellett over 4 years ago

    There isn't a single right answer here. I was about to vote for "distance is over 9 m" but then I thought of depth sounders, which both work under water and can sense over much greater distances than 9m. I don't know of any optical depth sounders !

     

    "Response speed must be fast" is the other possible, but how fast is fast ?

     

    MK

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +3 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
  • DAB
    DAB over 4 years ago

    Difficult question to answer.

    If you go optical, you need to consider if you are using IR or visible light.

    In general, both sensor require a rather clean environment. Both are susceptible to particle size obstructions.

     

    Definitely an application dependent decision.

     

    DAB

    • Cancel
    • Vote Up +5 Vote Down
    • Sign in to reply
    • More
    • Cancel
element14 Community

element14 is the first online community specifically for engineers. Connect with your peers and get expert answers to your questions.

  • Members
  • Learn
  • Technologies
  • Challenges & Projects
  • Products
  • Store
  • About Us
  • Feedback & Support
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal and Copyright Notices
  • Sitemap
  • Cookies

An Avnet Company © 2025 Premier Farnell Limited. All Rights Reserved.

Premier Farnell Ltd, registered in England and Wales (no 00876412), registered office: Farnell House, Forge Lane, Leeds LS12 2NE.

ICP 备案号 10220084.

Follow element14

  • X
  • Facebook
  • linkedin
  • YouTube